Contractor Bid Comparison Spreadsheet

0–10 scoring for each requirement

Editable Excel workbook

Clearer side-by-side comparison

From proposals to a decision

Price is only one part of a contractor bid.

Different proposals often hide important differences in scope, qualifications, scheduling, protections, and exclusions. CompareMetric puts those differences where you can see and evaluate them. Read our Contractor Bid Comparison Spreadsheet guide to organize bids beyond price.

Enter each proposal

Bring competing bids into one consistent, organized comparison.

Evaluate what matters

Score the factors that affect value—not just the quoted total.

Choose with confidence

See the full picture, identify tradeoffs, and document your decision.

The 10 / NOT / NET™ Method

Score each requirement from 0 to 10.

A 10 fully meets your ideal. Record significant disadvantages separately, ask every vendor the same questions, and compare qualified bids by NET score and price.

10Score each requirement from 0 to 10

NOTNote separate risks and deal breakers

ASKClarify each proposal in writing

NETCompare qualified bids and prices

Make the difference visible

One organized view. Better information. A smarter decision.

Explore how CompareMetric helps organize proposals, evaluate decision points, and compare value.

Editable comparison spreadsheet — Built in Excel and ready to edit

Ten evaluation points — Evaluate ten decision points

Full-value comparison — Compare full value

Organized decision documents — Decide with confidence

CompareMetric workbook shown on a computer screen

Included in your download

Everything you need to begin comparing.

Read Me First — read it free before buying
Quick Start Guide — read the full PDF free before buying
Excel Notebook — included after purchase
Reuse the Excel Notebook for future contractor projects
Instant download after purchase

Buy on Payhip Buy on Gumroad Buy on Etsy

Who it’s for

For homeowners comparing contractor proposals.

Use CompareMetric when you have competing bids for a renovation, repair, or other home project and want to understand the differences before choosing.

Bring your proposals and an Excel-compatible application. Make a fresh copy of the workbook for each project.

Portrait of Lumi, creator of CompareMetric

“I needed more than a simple list of pros and cons.”

Created by Lumi

Born from real-world decision making.

CompareMetric grew from my lifelong habit of turning complicated problems into clear, organized decisions. My professional background includes engineering, marketing, purchasing, and evaluating competing proposals.

Whenever several vendors offered different prices, features, conditions, and promises, I developed structured spreadsheets that made the differences visible, compared the offers fairly, and helped identify the choice that delivered the best overall value.

Lumi

Ready to compare bids with confidence?

Turn scattered contractor proposals into one clear, practical decision.

Buy on Payhip — $29 Buy on Gumroad — $29 Buy on Etsy — $29